Chapter 10: The Bureaucracy of Safetyism
The Conduct Policy Reminder: A College Student receives an email
-in the email it states administration is worried about your well-bing
-a request to meet with administration to discuss your options for support
-What did you do? You may ask.
-the email accuses you of engaging in a discussion of suicidal or self-destructive thoughts or actions with other students interferes with, or can hinder their pursuit of education and community
-the email tells you to refrain from discussing these issues with other students and use the appropriate resource listed below
-further, it states you do not involve other students in suicidal or self-destructive thoughts or action or you will face disciplinary action
-finished with our hope is now that you know exactly what could result in discipline, you can avoid putting yourself in that positon
-as you finish reading the email or rereading the email you may ask yourself how did the administration hear about such a conversation or you don’t even remember talking to other students about self-harm or suicidal thoughts
-you may even think this is absurd at you have no intention of hurting your self
So, why is the dean sending you a warning and a threat? And can the dean really tell you what you can and can’t say to your friends?
****This scenario is not fiction
-in 2015, a student at Northern Michigan University visited the campus counseling center to help in the aftermath of being sexually assaulted the year before
-she was not alone; 25-30 students per semester received a version of that email whether they expressed thoughts about suicide or self-harm
-it was NMU’s policy that students could be disciplined (and even expelled) for revealing these kinds of thoughts to other students
-the misguided policy was both stigmatizing and put suicidal students at an increased risk
-mental health professionals criticized this policy
***the dean believed that if students talked about their suffering, it would harm their friends
***this is an Untruth of Fragility (what doesn’t kill you makes you weaker) trumping common sense and basic humanity
-this is a kind of administration overkill
-universities teach cognitive distortions
-administrators are acting in ways that encourage students to embrace a distorted sense that they lack resilience
-they are acting as if students could not handle uncomfortable conversations or small slights from fellow students
-a growing campus bureaucracy has been unintentionally encouraging these bad intellectual habits for years and still do today
The Corporatization of College:
1963: multiversity
-in a multidiversity, different departments and power structures within a university pursue different goals in parallel
Ex. research, education, fundraising, branding, and legal compliance
-academic excellence priorities have morphed to resemble large corporation instead of a college campus
-there has been a fall of faculty as the administration over education has dramatically increased
-the faculty no longer plays a vital role in the university governance
-they have ceded much of that power to nonfaculty administrators
-the class of administrative specialists was established and became more distinct from the professor class
***administrators are more likely than professors to think that the way to solve a new campus problem is to create a new office to address the problem
The Customer is Always Right:
- few schools imposed any kind of penalty on students for shouting down speakers or disrupting classes, even though these actions usually violated their own codes of conduct
-many university presidents accepted ultimatums from students and then tried to meet many of the demands, usually without a word of criticism of the students’ tactics
***there governing ethos is one of “customer service”
-in a 2018 Washington Post article: “The fundamental cause of campus intolerance isn’t students’ extreme leftist or any other political ideology” but “a market-driven decision by universities, made decades ago, to treat students as consumers—who pay up to $60,000 per year for courses, excellent cuisine, comfortable accommodations and a lively campus life.”
-students have been allowed to prevent certain people from speaking on campus
-public universities is like purchasing what is essentially a luxury product
-customers can determine the curriculum and select all their desired amenities
-it stands to reason that they should also determine which speakers ought to be invited to campus and what opinions can be articulated in their midst
***The Consumerization Theory Fits
***education combines consumerism and safetyism simultaneously
How Campus Administrators Model Distorted Thinking:
-we need to understand other forces acting on administrators, including the fear of bad publicity and threats of litigation
administrators are bombarded with directives from in-house counsel, outside risk-management professionals, the school’s public relations team, and the upper echelons of the administration
-they must limit the university’s legal liability in everything from personal injury lawsuits to wrongful termination, and from intellectual property to wrongful-death actions
-this impacts why they are so keen to regulate what students do and say
1st Amendment: The warping of Freedom of Speech
-before 2013, the bedrock principle is that offensiveness alone is no justification for banning or restricting speech, especially on college campuses
-around 2013, more students seemed to be in agreement with administrators that they were unsafe
-that many aspects of students’ lives needed to be carefully regulated by adults, and that it was far better to overreact to potential risks and threats than to underreact
-campus administrators-usually with the best of intentions–were modeling distorted thinking
Overreaction Cases:
-overreaction cases are defined exactly as the name suggests: they are disproportionate responses to perceived offenses
“Almost all overreaction cases model the mental habit of catastrophizing, and communicate that disaster would result without the intervention of the administration.
Ex. Bergen Community College (2014)
-an art professor was placed on leave without pay and sent to psychological counseling for a social media post
-the daughter in the photo was wearing a shirt that had a dragon on it with the quote, “I will take what is mine with fire & blood” in reference to the popular TV series Game of Thrones
-an administrator insisted that “fire” could refer to an AK-47
Ex. Oakton Community College (2015)
-a professor received a cease-and-desist letter from his college based on a one-sentence email he had sent to a few colleagues
-his email noted that May Day is a time “when workers across the world celebrate their struggle for union rights and remember the Haymarket riot in Chicago.”
-the college alleged that the reference to the 1889 riot was threatening to the college president, because she was one of the recipients of the email
-this assumes it was a threat because the riot “resulted in 11 deaths and more than 70 people injured”
Overregulation Cases:
-over regulation is less about policing actual offenses than it is about preventing potential offense
-it is a continuation of over protective helicopter parenting
-administrators tightly regulate students in order to keep them “safe”
-speech remains a common target of overregulation
-”politically correct” speech codes have been challenged in court which end up being revised, abandoned, or ruled unconstitutional
Examples:
Vague and overboard speech codes:
-University of Connecticut’s ban on “inappropriately directed laughter”
-it dropped the code as part of a settlement in 1990
-Drexel University had the same code verbatim but was eventually repealed
-Alabama’s Jacksonville State University had a “no student shall offend anyone on University property”
-University of West Alabama’s code prohibited “harsh text messages or emails”
***these codes teach students to use an overbroad and entirely subjective standard for determining wrongdoing
***they exemplify the Untruth of Emotional Reasoning: Always trust your feeling
-if you feel offended, then a punishable offense must have occurred
-speech codes like these teach the Untruth of Fragility
-they communicate that offensive speech or inappropriate laughter might be so damaging that administrators must step in to protect vulnerable and fragile students
-they empower college administrators to ensure that authority figures are always available to “resolve” verbal conflicts
Free Speech Zones:
-Universities never seem to tire of creating “free speech zones” with restrict certain kinds of speech and expression to tiny and often remote parts of campus
-in the 1960s and 70s honored places where students could always engage in free speech
“College handbooks today, you will find policies affecting many other aspects of students’ lives, including what they can post on social media, what they can say in the dormitories to one another, and what they can do off campus-including what organization they can join.”
-overreaction and overregulation are usually the work of people within bureaucratic structures who have developed a mindset commonly known as CYA (cover your ass)
-they can be held responsible for any problem that arises on their watch
-if they took no action to prevent it, so they often adopt a defensive stance
-overreacting is better than underacting, overregulating is better than underregulating, and caution is better than courage
-this attitude reinforces the safetyism mindset that many students learn in childhood
See Something, Say Something:
-today’s college students were raised in the fearful years after the attacks of September 11, 2001
-government was telling us, “If you see something, say something”
-adults were told to follow their most anxious feelings
-it was an embrace of the Untruth of Emotional Reasoning: Always trust your feelings “If it doesn’t feel right, it probably isn’t”
***now young people have come to believe that danger lurks everywhere, even in the classroom, and even in private conversations
Examples:
-2016, New York University: administration placed signs in the restrooms urging everyone to take a “feel-something say-something” approach to speech
-the signs outline how to report one another anonymously if they experience “bias, discrimination, or harassment
-it was called the “Bias Response Line”
-2017, institutions were using a catalog to spotlight on Speech Codes database
Psychological Experiments:
-have shown that to be human is to have biases
-we are biased toward ourselves and our ingroups, toward attractive people, toward people who have done us favors, and even toward people who share our name or birthday
-most interested in negative biases based on identity categories, such as race, gender, and sexual orientation
-there are high levels of widespread microaggressions being seen as dangerous
-more difficult to develop a sense of trust between professors and students in such an environment
-allows for students to report a professor for something said or shown even before the lecture had ended
-professors feeling like they are “walking on eggshells”
-professors as eliminating any material from the syllabus or lecture that could leave to a complaint
-students miss out on opportunities to develop intellectual antifragility
Harassment and concept Creep:
***Being offended is different from discrimination
-what counts as harassment is high a pattern of severe behavior that “effectively denies access to an education opportunity or benefit”
-the pattern of behavior must also be discriminatory directed at someone who belongs to a protected class named in the statute, such as gender, race, or religion
Examples:
-2005, University of Central Florida, a student was charged with harassment through “personal abuse” for creating a Facebook group and made a comment about a candidate (offensive yes dangerous no)
-a janitor was reading a book about how the Irish defeated the KKK (1920s) historical
-the image on the cover was upsetting to two people and reported him
-lowering the bar that far trivializes the real harm that true harassment can do
***the purpose of these laws is to protect students from unlawful acts, not to empower censors
Examples:
-University of Michigan speech code: prohibited creating a “demeaning” environment through speech that “stigmatizes or victimizes an individual
-2013: Department and Justice issued a new definition of harassment
“Unwelcome conduct of a sexual nature” including “verbal, nonverbal, or physical conduct”
-this definition was not limited to speech that would be offensive to a reasonable person, nor did it require that the alleged target actually be offended-both requirements of traditional harassment claims
-by eliminating the reasonable-person standard, harassment was left to be defined by the self-reported subjective experience of every member of the university community
***emotional reasoning turned into a federal regulation
-Professor Laura Kipnis in Northwestern’s wrote an article regarding sexual misconduct policies included prohibition on romantic relationships between adult student and faculty or staff
-student activists claimed that her article created a hostile environment
-Kipnis dealt with criticism, complaints, and subjected to investigations which all lasted for two years
“All of these protections were not making people less vulnerable, they were making people more vulnerable” and “Students are going to be impeded when they leave university and go out into the world, and nobody is going to protect them from the multitudes of injuries and slights and that kind of thing that we all have to deal with in the course of daily life.”
How to Foster Moral Dependency:
2014 Essay by two sociologists
-explained where this new culture of vulnerability
-they called it “victimhood culture”
-they interpreted it as a new moral order that was in conflict with the older “dignity culture”
-functioning dignity culture, people are assumed to have dignity and worth regardless of what others think of them, so they are not expected to react too strongly to minor slights
-people are expected to have enough self-control to shrug off irritations, slights, and minor conflicts as they pursue their own projects
-violations of one’s rights, there are reliable legal or administrative remedies
-perspective is a key element of a dignity culture; people don’t view disagreements, unintentional slights, or even direct insults as threats to their dignity that must always be met with a response
Ex. a dignity culture: children learn some version of “sticks and stones”
-people can feel pain as a result of words, but a dignity culture use to dismiss an insult
2013: Changes on Campuses
-the interlocking set of new ideas about microaggressions, trigger warnings, and safe spaces
-the emerging morality of victimhood culture was radically different from dignity culture
-groups display high sensitivity to slight
-a tendency to handle conflicts through complaints to third parties
-they seek to cultivate an image of being victims who deserve assistance
-administrators or legal authorities who can be persuaded to take one’s side and intervene is a prerequisite for the emergence of victim hood culture
Moral dependence:
-people come to rely on external authorities to resolve their problems, and, over time, “their willingness or ability to use other forms of conflict management may atrophy.”
-overprotective policies make students more vulnerable instead of less, and that schools are creating a culture of vulnerability
“The growing tendency to cultivate vulnerability in students carries unacknowledged costs,” and asked students to talk to each other rather than relying on administration interventions
***this is a cycle of dependence
In Sum:
-but good intentions can sometimes lead to policies that are bad for students
-campuses are run like a corporation
-increase of consumerist mentality about higher education
-students have become customers
-professors have adopted the “better safe than sorry” approach to lesson and content
-convey imminent danger even when there is little or no real threat
-administrators model multiple cognitive distortions, promote the Untruth of Fragility, and contribute to the culture of safetyism
-regulations by administrators restrict freedom of speech often with highly subjective definitions of key concepts
-campus suggesting that freedom of speech can or should be restricted because of some students’ emotional discomfort
-this teaches catastrophizing and mind reading, cognitive distortions and promotes the Untruth of Emotional Reasoning
-administrators create a “Bias Response LInes” and “Bias Response Teams”
-this making reporting on one another anonymously for “bias,” “feel something say something,” approach is likely to erode trust within a community
-resolving problems and conflicts can have the unintended consequence of fostering moral dependence