Chapter 11: The Quest for Justice
-Millennials or iGen; they lean left on most social issues and many economic ones
-they are less religious than previous generations
-the events political climate in the last few years influences the way today’s college students vote for the rest of their lives
-iGen born in 1995
-turned 14 in 2006
-Obama sworn in, 1st iPhone and smart phones became common to teenagers
-arrived on a college campus in 2013
-the political events and positions invaded tweets, social media posts, the rise of podcasts
-in 2013 there was a government shutdown and the stock market rose
-the interests and activism of teens have far mor todo with social issues and injustices than with purely economic or political concerns
-what is commonly known as “social justice” has increased each year since iGen turned 14
-2009-10 saw in increase or high-profile social justice stories and continues to increase each year
Ex.
2013-Black Lives Matter founded
2014-Black Lives Matter protests spread across America, lead in the drinking water in Flint, Michigan, raises awareness of “environmental justice”
2015-Gay marriage legalized, Kaitlyn Jenner publicaly identifies as a worman, Confederate flags removed from the state capital in South Carolina, universities erupt in protests over racism
2016-attack on gay nightclub in Orlando, Florida, Colin Kaepernick refuses to stand for the national anthem, transgender people must use the bathrooms corresponding to the sex on their birth certificates, election of Donald Trump
2017-Trum attempts to enact various “Muslim bans,” women’s march in Washington, violent protests against campus speakers, Trump bans trnasgender people from military service, largest mass shooting in U.S. history in Las Vegas, the start of the #MeToo movement
2018-Parkland, Florida high school shooting kills seventeen, students organize school walkouts and marches for gun control across the United States
-add on the amplifying power of social media
-this generation has been exposed to endless streams of videos showing innocent people-mostly people of color-being beaten, killed, or deported by armed servicemen
***no wonder they have developed an extraordinary passion for social justice
-social justice is a lightening rod in the left-right culture war
“The way social justice is currently being conceptualized and pursued on campus is causing a variety of problems and engendering resistance and resentment for reasons that some of its advocates don’t seem to recognize.”
Intuitive Justice:
-justice is arguably the most important moral concept in the history of Western philosophy
-Plato’s Republic tried to propose rules and principles that would underlie a fair or “just” society
-intuitive justice is the combination of distributive justice = the perception that the process by which things are distributed and rules are enforced is fair and trustworthy
Distributive Justice:
-sharing plays a big role in the moral lives of children, and they get a lot of practice dividing things equally
-even toddlers seem to recognize the importance of proportionality (it is fair if each one gets an even slice of cake or each get 3 same sized cookies)
-6 year olds show a clear preference for rewarding the hard worker in a group even if equal pay is an option
-young kids have trouble following intuition when it means that they themselves get less reward
-adolescents are much better applying proportionality to themselves
“Humans naturally favour fair distributions not equal to one,” and “when fairness and equality clash, people prefer fair inequality over unfair equality.”
***distributive justice calls for equality
Ex. a common intuition that money inherited from a deceased parent be divided equally among siblings rather than who did more for the parents or who in the family needs the money more
***distributive justice can call for inequality
Ex. attending to a need where the family or group has communal feelings that thinks it fair to route resources to whoever needs them most
Proportionality:
-this is the heart of “equity theory”
-the major theory of distributive justice in social psychology
-its core assertion is that when the ratio of outcomes to inputs is equal for all participants, people perceive that to be equitable, or fair
-equity theory: people keep close track of how much reward each person is reaping
(their outcomes, such as pay and perks)
-in proportion to how much they are contributing
(their inputs, such as hours worked and the skills or credentials they bring)
-even in marriages, people are not oblivious to inputs and outcomes so they too look at who is doing their “fair share” of some or all tasks
***when everyone perceives that things are fair and harmony is far more likely
***when people believe that someone else’s ration is too high, they are likely to feel resentful toward that person, whose rewards are disproportionate to their contributions
Procedural Justice:
-intuitive justice is not just how much a person gets, but it is also about the process by which decisions about distributions are made
-people are much more willing to accept a decision or action, even one that goes against themselves, when they perceive that the process that led to the decision was fair
Two basic concerns:
1-is how the decision is being made
-this includes whether the decision-makers are doing their best to be objective and neutral and are therefore trustworthy
-or whether they have conflicts of interest, prejudice, or other factors that lead them to be biased in favor of a particular person or outcomes
-this includes transparency
2-is the basic concern is how a person is being treated along the way
-which means are people being treated with dignity, and do they have a voice
-do they get to fully state their case and are they taken seriously when they do
***this is especially important for understanding how people respond to the police
1-when people perceive that the police are following fair procedures and treating them and people like them with dignity, they are much more willing to support the police, help them fight crime, and even accept occasionally being stopped and frisked by the police
2-if people think that the way the police select people to frisk is racially biased and that people like them are treated disrespectfully, with hostility, or, even worse, with violence, they are angry and will see police as the enemy
“If you want to motivate people to support a new policy or join a movement in the name of justice, you need to activate in them a clear perception, or intuition, that someone didn’t get what he or she deserved (distributive injustice) or that someone was a victim of an unfair process (procedural injustice). If you canT elicit at least one of those feelings, then people are much more likely to be content with the status quo, even if it is one in which some people or groups end up with more resources or more status than others.”
Proportional-Procedural Social Justice:
-some conservatives and libertarians have argued that “social justice” is a useless term–there is only justice and tacking on the word “social” adds nothing
***Social justice is the view that everyone deserves equal economic, political and social rights and opportunities
-most people would agree that everyone should have equal rights and opportunities and that doors should be open for everyone
-the legt-right divide on social policy involves how far the government should go to equalize opportunity for children who are born into unequal circumstances
-there is a divide on whether it is the federal government, state governments, or local governments that should be responsible for the equalization
***using the definition of social justice you can make socially disadvantaged categories
Ex. Practical use of social justice
-1965 JIm Crow Laws in the South
-explicit violations of procedural justice: racist police, judges, and legislatures cruelly disregarded the dignity of black Americans and brutally violated their rights
-these violations of procedural justice lead directly to egregious violations of distributive justice in almost every area of life including very unequal public expenditures on separate and vastly unequal schools
-the civil rights campaign was along struggle for proportional-procedural social justice
-this was calling attention to cases in which people are denied dignity and rights
***new laws that supported widely shared new norms such as the civil rights struggle of the 1960s is the definition of moral and social progress
***Justice requires truth and honesty, and justice is entirely compatible with the purpose, values, and daily life in communities including universities.
***but when social justice activists focus on a desired end-state and pursue that goal in ways that violate either distributive or procedural justice
Equal-Outcomes Social Justice:
-the implementation of Title IX has changed over the years’
-the original goal of providing equal access to educational opportunities for women and men
-the program morphed into one that pushes universities to obtain equal outcomes regardless of inputs
-1979: men and women should find it equally easy to obtain a sports-related scholarship or a slot on a team
-1996: the Clinton administration began to put pressure on schools to achieve equal outcomes
-sports programs (taken all together) must have a gender balance of the overall student body
-schools therefore began to strive for equal outcomes, so had to cut men’s sports teams as part of their effort to improve their gender balance
“Of course, if male and female students had equal labels of interest in participating in sports, then both versions of social justice would converge on the desired end-state of equal outcomes.”
-equal outcomes in these cases doesn’t necessarily mean fifty-fifty
-equal outcomes means that of all the students who participate in sports, the ratio of men to women will be the same as the ratio of men to women in the student body as a whole
-equal outcomes social justice activists seem to believe that all institutions and occupations should mirror all overall U.S. population
Ex. 50% female, roughly 15% African American, 15% Latino, and so on….
***any departure from those numbers means that a group is “underrepresented,” and underrepresentation is often taken to be direct evidence of systemic bias or injustice
“When the federal government pressures universities to achieve equal outcomes in the face of unequal inputs, administrators do what they can to protect the institution. That might require them to violate procedural justice, distributive justice, and honesty along the way.”
-it’s very hard to make it intuitively compelling by linking it to equity theory or procedural fairness
-most people want individuals to be treated well
-they recoil from cases where individuals are treated unfairly in order to bring about some kind of group-level equality
-this is why quotas generally produce such strong backlash
-they mandate a violation of procedural justice (people treated differently based on their race, sex, or some other factor) and distributive justice (rewards are not proportional to inputs) to achieve a specific end-state of equal outcomes
Correlation Does Not IMply Causation:
-all social scientists know that correlation does not imply causation
“Ideas may not be accepted not because they are true but because the politically dominant group wants them to be true in order to promote its preferred narrative and preferred set of remedies.”
-the passion and certainty of activists, flawed academic theories may get carried out of the academy and be applied in high schools, corporations, and other organizations
“When reformers try to intervene in complex institutions using theories that are based on a flawed or incomplete understanding of the causal forces at work, their reform efforts are unlikely to do any good–and might even make things worse.”
In Sum:
-intuitive notions of justice include two major types: distributive justice (the perception that people are getting what they deserve) and procedural justice (the perception that the process by which things are distributed and rules are enforced is fair and trustworthy
-social justice is a central concept in campus life today
***social justices activists are willing to violate distributive or procedural fairness for some individuals along the way
***these efforts violate many people’s sense of intuitive justice
Chapter 12 and on are what to do with your kids, colleges, and societies